RETURNS POLICY
Blue Nile Return & Exchange Service
Returning an item is simple and fully covered—here’s what to expect:
• 30-day returns on eligible items
• Fully insured return shipping at no cost
• Simple online and customer support options
• Refund or exchange available
Holiday Extended Return Policy
As a valued customer, we want to help ensure you have a memorable holiday shopping experience. To provide added flexibility during the holiday season, Blue Nile™ is offering an extended return window for eligible purchases.
Extended Holiday Return Policy
For orders placed on or after November 1st through December 5th, customers may return eligible items through January 5, 2026, subject to all other applicable return policy terms and conditions.
Please note: Personalized jewelry, custom orders, engraved items, items re-sized after initial purchase, Diamond Upgrade program purchases, Clearance, and “Final Sale" items are not eligible for return or exchange.
For orders placed after December 5th, Blue Nile's standard 30-day return policy will apply.
30-Day Returns Overview
We offer returns within 30 days on eligible items, so you can shop with confidence. If your order isn’t exactly right, you can return it in its original condition for a full refund or exchange.
Our return process is simple, secure and easy to manage from start to finish.
Return Eligibility Requirements
To qualify for returns, items must meet the following requirements:
• 30 days from shipment date: Returns must be initiated within 30 days of the shipment date. Please note this timeframe begins when your order ships, not when it is delivered.
• Unworn, original condition: Items must show no signs of wear or alteration.
• Original packaging: Include all packaging provided with your order, such as the ring box and any inserts.
• Documentation: Include all original paperwork, such as diamond grading reports or certificates, if applicable.
What Isn't Covered Under Blue Nile Returns and Exchanges
The following Blue Nile purchases are not eligible for return or exchange:
• Personalized jewelry
• Custom orders
• Engraved items
• Items resized after purchase
• Items resized after initial purchase
• Diamond Upgrade Program purchases
• Program purchases
• Clearance items
• Final sale items
Custom and made-to-order items can be changed or canceled within 24 hours of payment by contacting Customer Service at 1-800-242-2728; after that, or once production has begun, changes and cancellations may not be permitted.
Free Return Shipping
Blue Nile free returns include shipping for eligible items. For eligible items returned within 30 days of shipment. Each return includes a fully insured label to help protect your item in transit.
Two complimentary return shipments are included per customer each year for eligible items returned in the 30-day purchase window. After that, customers may be responsible for arranging and paying for return shipping and insurance.
How to Start a Return
To initiate a return or exchange, follow these steps to access your order and begin the process:
1. Locate your order: Sign in to your account and visit the “Your Orders” section. You can also start the process through online chat by providing your order number, or visit a Blue Nile Showroom in your area.
2. Start your return: Select your order and follow the prompts to initiate your return or exchange. You can also start the process through online chat by providing your order number.
3. Receive your return label: If your return qualifies for complimentary return shipping, U.S. customers can download a prepaid, fully insured shipping label and instructions immediately, and a copy is emailed to you. International customers receive a return airway bill and instructions by email within 1–2 business days.
4. Need assistance? If you’d like help at any point, contact our team 7 days a week, 5am-2am EST, at 1-800-242-2728 or service@bluenile.com, or visit our Contact Us page.
Return Process & Instructions
Once you've initiated your return, follow the provided instructions to prepare and ship your item. Requirements may vary slightly by location, but the process is designed to be clear and secure at every step.
Packaging & Documentation Requirements
When returning your item, be sure to include all original packaging and documentation. This includes any boxes, inserts, and paperwork, such as diamond grading reports if applicable.
US vs. International Returns
Return steps and timing may vary based on your location:
• U.S. returns: You can download your fully insured return shipping label and instructions immediately after initiating your return. A copy will also be sent to your email.
• International returns: Your return airway bill (international shipping document) and instructions will be emailed to you within 1-2 business days.
Track or Manage Your Return
Once your return has been initiated, you can track its progress from the Your Orders page in your account. There, you can view your return status and confirm when it has been received and processed.
For additional details regarding Blue Nile's return and exchange policy, please visit our Return Policy page.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I return my order?
For online shopping with fully covered returns, visit the My Orders page in your account to initiate and access your return details. You can also use online chat, contact Customer Service at 1-800-242-2728 or service@bluenile.com, or visit a Blue Nile Showroom in your area.
How long do I have to return a Blue Nile Order?
You have 30 days from the shipment date to return eligible items. Returns must be initiated within this timeframe, and items must meet all eligibility requirements.
Are there items that cannot be returned?
Yes. Personalized jewelry, custom orders, engraved items, items resized after initial purchase, Diamond Upgrade Program purchases, clearance items and “Final Sale” items are not eligible for return or exchange.
How long does it take for a credit to process?
Once your return is received, it is typically processed within one to two weeks. After processing, your refund is issued to your bank within three business days, although it may take up to 10 additional business days for your financial institution to post the funds to your account.
How do I start a Blue Nile return?
Initiate your return through your account, online chat or by contacting our team. Once your return is set up, you’ll receive instructions and a prepaid return shipping label to complete the process.
Who pays for return shipping?
Blue Nile covers the cost of return shipping for eligible items returned within 30 days. You’ll receive a prepaid, insured label when you begin your return. Each customer is eligible for two complimentary returns per year.
Related Content
For more information, explore the following helpful guides: