Sell Your Diamonds and Jewelry to CIRCA

Simple and Rewarding Selling Experience

As part of our Jeweler for Life commitment, Blue Nile has partnered with CIRCA, a world leader in buying pre-owned jewelry, to bring you a simple and transparent service to sell your diamonds, jewelry and watches. Visit them in person at any of their 14 worldwide locations or use their free and fully insured mail-in service from the comfort of your home.

Selling Your Diamonds, Jewelry and Watches to CIRCA is easy!

Immediate payment in cash or 110% of CIRCA's offer towards a Blue Nile gift card

Putting an engagement ring into a CIRCA bag

Online Mail-in Service

  • Tell CIRCA about your diamonds, jewelry, and watches
  • Receive an offer range
  • Send your item/s for final inspection
  • Upon acceptance of final offer, receive immediate payment (cash or 110% of the offer value as a Blue Nile gift card)
A man inspecting an engagement ring with a loop

In-person Private Consultation

  • Schedule an appointment at any CIRCA location worldwide: New York area, South Florida, Chicago, San Francisco, Beverly Hills, Bethesda, Spain and Hong Kong
  • Meet privately with a CIRCA jewelry expert
  • Receive a written offer on the spot
  • Upon acceptance of offer, receive immediate payment (cash or 110% of the offer value as a Blue Nile gift card)

Learn why CIRCA is the only jewelry buyer Blue Nile recommends

Handcrafted Quality

Learn why CIRCA is the only jewelry buyer Blue Nile recommends

Trusted Expertise:
CIRCA's expertise comes from their experience. CIRCA has bought more than $500 million worth of diamonds, jewelry and watches from many thousands of clients for over twenty years. With great client reviews from thousands of clients, CIRCA's expertise is sought all over the world.
Best Value:
CIRCA is the world leader in understanding the value of diamonds, jewelry, and watches. With an unparalleled global sales reach, you'll receive maximum value for the jewelry you want to sell.
Immediate Payment:
CIRCA's vast experience in all manner of diamonds, watches and jewelry, coupled with tremendous financial resources means that CIRCA's offers and payments are immediate.
Luxurious Selling Experience:
whether your appointment is physical and you visit one of 14 worldwide locations - or virtual, and take advantage of CIRCA's exclusive, free and fully insured mail-in service, you'll enjoy your experience with a CIRCA specialist.
Simple & Secure:
CIRCA's mail-in service is simple, safe, and fully insured. CIRCA will send you a free and fully insured shipping kit to safely pack your diamonds, jewelry and watches. There is never any obligation to sell, and no hidden fees to use their services.
Payment Options that Suit Your Needs:
choose to receive cash payment (check or bank wire), or receive the offer value and an extra 10% towards a Blue Nile gift card. The Blue Nile gift card can be used on any product available on, can be used in part or in full value and has no expiry date.

Frequently Asked Questions

Loose diamonds or diamonds set in jewelry of all shapes, colors, and sizes. They do not, however, purchase lab grown diamonds or simulants.
Branded Jewelry:
Jewelry by famous makers such as Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels, David Webb, Boucheron, Verdura, Bucellatti, Bulgari, Schlumberger, Mauboussin, and others.
Fine Jewelry:
Diamond jewelry, diamond studs, diamond earrings, diamond bracelets, diamond necklaces, fine gold jewelry, Emerald, Sapphire, and Ruby jewelry.
Antique Jewelry:
Period jewelry including Antique, Edwardian, Georgian, Art Nouveau, Belle Epoque, Art Deco, Retro, Modern and more.
Rolex, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, Panerai, Breguet, Breitling, Vacheron Constantin, Richard Mille, Cartier, and more. This includes steel sport models, vintage, and gold watches.

Original paperwork and boxes are great and may increase collector interest and improve value. However, they are not necessary to sell your jewelry.

CIRCA does not recommend polishing, refurbishing, or replacing any original parts of your jewelry or watches. This can diminish value if done poorly.

Online Mail-In:
CIRCA's mail-in service is simple, free and secure. After you provide information about the jewelry you are looking to sell, a CIRCA specialist will provide you with an estimated offer range. CIRCA will then mail you a free and fully insured shipping kit overnight. Once received by CIRCA, a specialist will make you a final offer to purchase your jewelry. Should you accept, payment will be remitted same day by check or bank wire. Should you decide to keep some or all of your pieces, CIRCA will ship these items back to you, free of charge, no questions asked.
In-person Private Consultation:
On the day of your appointment, a CIRCA specialist will examine with you the diamonds, jewelry or watches you're interested in selling in a private setting. CIRCA will make a written offer and immediate payment should you accept.

United States:
Bethesda, MD
Beverly Hills, CA
Boca Raton, FL
Chicago, IL
Evanston, IL
Greenwich, CT
New York City, NY
Palm Beach, FL
Palo Alto, CA
San Francisco, CA
Short Hills, NJ
Barcelona, Spain
Madrid, Spain
Hong Kong

CIRCA will issue payment the same day you accept their offer. Payments are made by check or bank wire, according to your preference.

No, there are no fees nor commissions charged. Both CIRCA's in-person appointments and their online mail-in services are free, even if you decide not to sell.