1
2
3
Unique Engagement Rings
Your love story is anything but ordinary, and your proposal deserves the standout style of creative, non-traditional engagement rings. We offer unique diamond rings, gemstone designs, two-tone bands, and custom designs to help you find a ring that’s as special as your soulmate. These out-of-the-box designs take classic components and give them a clever twist, making them one-of-a-kind treasures that last a lifetime. Explore our handcrafted unique engagement rings for every style and budget.
On Sale
Engravable
Unique
Sort By
Shipping Date By
119 Results
Customize Your Ring
Creative Studio
Design a Ring That's Truly Yours.
Setting Price Starting From
$740
Customize Your Ring
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
☆
FAQs about Unique Engagement Rings
What is a unique engagement ring?
A unique engagement ring is one that has creative designs with lots of personality, typically set with different kinds of diamonds and gemstones. They can feature different precious metals, two-tone designs, unusual setting styles, customizations, and more elements that help them stand out from the crowd. Unique engagement rings, also known as non-traditional rings or alternative engagement rings, showcase the wearer’s style and spirit.
Unique engagement rings march to the beat of their own drum. These are rings that often feature unexpected elements such as twisted bands, multicolor metals and alternative stones like gemstone engagement rings. They're a departure from classic engagement rings and often include non-traditional elements or designs. East-West ring settings, designs with split shanks or styles with gemstone halos are also beautiful options for unique engagement rings.
Which metal should I choose for my engagement ring?
Are there matching wedding bands for unique rings?
Many of the unique engagement rings we sell at Blue Nile are specifically designed to work with a matching wedding band, making your shopping experience easier.
Are unique-style engagement rings more expensive than solitaire engagement rings?
Not necessarily. In a solitaire engagement ring, the center stone is the focal point, and many people choose a higher carat weight. Unique wedding rings and engagement designs offer additional style features that can make the center stone look bigger or clearer, helping to maximize any ring buying budget.
The setting style, gemstones, diamonds, and customizations you choose will all influence the cost of your chosen unique engagement ring. We offer a wide variety of non-traditional engagement rings for every budget. Our unique diamond rings will generally cost more than unique engagement rings with gemstones, but the exact price difference will vary from one ring to the next. The cost of unique rings varies depending on the designs and stones you choose.
Are unique engagement rings custom?
Unique engagement rings can be bespoke or selected from existing designs. We offer a wide selection of unique engagement ring settings along with custom engagement rings that make the perfect unique ring.
Do non-traditional engagement rings come with diamond designs?
Yes, unique diamond rings are an option for those taking the non-traditional route. While diamonds are a traditional stone for engagement rings, incorporating less traditional elements such as two tone metals, twisted bands or filigree detailing can make the ring more unique.
Which styles are most popular for unique rings?
Unique engagement rings are incredibly varied and often custom. Popular styles include alternative center stones, twisted bands, cluster engagement rings, two-stone engagement rings, rings with gemstones, vintage-inspired engagement rings, and non-traditional rings with fancy-color diamonds.
Who sells unique engagement rings?
If you’ve been searching for where to buy unique engagement rings, look no further than our selections at Blue Nile. We offer a leading selection of non-traditional rings in a range of sizes and styles, perfect for anyone looking to stand out.
How do I find the right ring size?
You can find the perfect fit with our free printable ring sizer.
Are non-traditional engagement rings with gemstones available?
Yes! In addition to offering a leading selection of unique diamond rings, we also offer non-traditional engagement rings with gemstones and birthstones. Some of the most popular unique engagement rings for women and men feature colorful gemstones.
How do I find out the best ring style for my partner?
Unique diamond rings and gemstone styles are standout settings, but it’s important to ensure that these kinds of styles fit the wearer.
Take a look at your partner’s existing jewelry collection and see how it may speak to their tastes when it comes to engagement rings. Do they have a large collection of more whimsical pieces, or do they prefer traditional jewelry looks? You can also ask friends and family about your partner’s jewelry tastes, or even ask your partner directly if you’re able to do so without revealing your upcoming proposal.
Our engagement ring style quiz and engagement ring buying guide can also help you learn more about your partner’s styles and whether a unique engagement ring is the best fit for them. Our experts are also here to help, you can visit one of our local jewelry stores or schedule a virtual jewelry shopping appointment to get started on choosing the perfect unique wedding rings and engagement styles for your partner.
Can I customize unique engagement rings?
Absolutely! You can choose the exact diamond or gemstone you’d like featured in your unique ring. We also offer further customization options to help build the perfect non-traditional, creative, whimsical, alternative, or simply cool design that’s best for your partner. Contact us to learn more about our bespoke unique engagement rings.
