Gemstone Engagement Rings

Show off your love of colour with a stunning gemstone engagement ring. Shop our array of beautiful gemstone ring options at Blue Nile, whether you’re looking for a vibrant alternative to a traditional diamond centre stone or you want to create a ring with gemstones and diamonds. Rich, blue sapphires pair beautifully with icy diamonds, and ruby stones have their own timeless beauty.


15 of 117 Gemstone Engagement Rings

Quick Shipping

FAQs about Gemstone Engagement Rings

Blue Nile features gemstones in a wide variety of setting styles, including pavé, halo, diamond sidestone, infinity twist, and solitaire.

Gemstone engagement rings are unique and captivating. Start your search with a sapphire or ruby, which displays intense colour, or buy a gemstone engagement ring based on the significance or meaning of the stone. Some gemstones are too low on the Mohs hardness scale to survive everyday wear. These include beryl, quartz stones like emerald and amethyst, and soft stones like moonstone and morganite.

Because many of our gemstone rings are designed as cocktail or special occasion rings rather than engagement rings, they don't offer a matching wedding band. That being said, there are many different wedding band styles that will coordinate seamlessly with these designs.

At Blue Nile, the most popular engagement ring is the round brilliant diamond solitaire. When you're looking for something less traditional, play around with different setting styles and diamond shapes.

Top Gemstone Engagement Ring Reviews

Gemstone Engagement Ring with Sapphire Review

Gorgeous gem!

This ring is beautiful especially for a girl who likes colour on her ring finger. I got it as my 13th wedding anniversary addition to my Luna Sapphire band and another diamond band. It stacks nicely and has amazing sparkle to both diamonds and the main stone.
Gosia C. - Verified Buyer
Average Customer Rating $5 out of 5 stars
Sapphire and Diamond Ring
18k White Gold (8x6mm)

EUR 5,070.00

now: EUR 3,802.50

Gemstone Sidestone Engagement Ring Review

Ring of My Dreams!

My fiancé did an amazing job by going through Blue Nile to get my ring. It absolutely exceeded expectations and I still can’t stop staring at my finger! Highly recommend Blue Nile as a company and especially this ring!
Peyton C. - Verified Buyer
Average Customer Rating $5 out of 5 stars
Morganite and Diamond Halo Ring
14k Rose Gold (11x9mm)

EUR 1,850.00

now: EUR 1,125.00

Gemstone Engagement Ring with aquamarine review

Beautiful Ring

Stunning cut on an incredible aquamarine stone floating on a bed of diamonds.
William T. - Verified Buyer
Average Customer Rating $5 out of 5 stars
Aquamarine and Diamond Milgrain Halo Ring
14k White Gold (8mm)

EUR 1,275.00

now: EUR 645.00

Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring Review

Gorgeous Ring

This ring is absolutely beautiful and comes packaged perfectly. The diamonds in the double halo setting are radiant and sparkly, and the ruby in the middle is beautifully cut. Although the ring is expensive, the price is worth it because this ring's design is flawless and made with high-quality gems and rose gold. Would definitely recommend!
Lauren N. - Verified Buyer
Average Customer Rating $5 out of 5 stars
Oval Ruby Ring
Double Diamond Halo 14k Rose Gold (7x5mm)

EUR 3,900.00

now: EUR 2,340.00


Explore More Gemstone Engagement Rings

Have questions about gemstone engagement rings?

Get answers day or night.