More Reviews
Results: 68 Reviews
Sort by:
OVERALL PRODUCT RATING:





4.7 out of 5
(68 Reviews)
5 Stars
49
4 Stars
19
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0





Most beautiful pair of diamonds I have ever seen..
Exceptional quality diamond earrings. Unfortunately, platinum four prong basket that diamond sits on is larger than the other and makes one earrings noticeably larger and I had to ship them back for repair. Other than this issue, diamonds itself were exceptional.





Exquisite!
They are absolutely beautiful! BETTER than I ever imagined. They are absolutely perfect and in store you would pay double what you get them for on here! Do your research - you will come back and buy here!





The Perfect 30th Anniversary
Quality and workmanship was exquisite. The accompanying data package characterized the diamond as purchased. Would of rated "Exceptional" but the thickness of the earring backing was "too thin" and proned to bending when getting on.





Beautiful and comfortable
Love, love, love my earrings! I'm highly allergic to most metals but platinum is not irritating. They're beautiful and comfortable. Thank for the great product and great service!





Great earrings!
The earrings looked great and the choices that were available online were excellent.





Great diamonds
Exactly what I expected when ordered. Each diamond is certified and the setting looks exactly as shown online.





Blue Nile makes it easy to get exactly what you want. I wanted something a little different and wife loves them. Never saw her so happy.





When she opened the box she loved them. The first thing she said was they big and pretty and matches the ring in which I also order from Blue Nile three years earlier. Would not suggest any other seller but Blue Nile.





Gorgeous
The diamonds were just as I expected, and with the policy for returns and upgrades it was an easy decision for me.





Love my asscher cut earrings!
I've been thinking about getting asscher cut earrings for awhile now. I've looked around and there's no comparison with Blue Nile's quality, service and price! I love my 2.01 TW asscher earrings on four-prong platinum. I chose to do build your own earrings and I got what I wanted and stil stayed within my budget.





She's gonna be surprised.
Blue Nile has an amazing selection of jewelry. I sat here for hours browsing their diamonds trying to find the perfect ones for my wife.
Also, Blue Nile has the best customer service I've ever had to deal with. I was having issues with my bank letting my transaction go through when I was using my debit card for 3 weeks and Blue Nile held my order for me while I dealt with the issue.
I bought my wife's engagement ring and we bought our wedding rings here along with the earrings she doesn't know about yet. I will always come back to Blue Nile for any jewelry I buy.





I love my earrings
They are beautiful and arrived fast! The price for quality was great compared to many other places. I also like that I was able to build my own earrings!





Earrings are a Great Value
The earrings are a great value and even though the diamonds are sizable the way they are set makes them appear even larger. My wife was extremely pleased with them.
We shopped at a variety of local and national jewelers before we purchased them from Blue Nile. No one could come close to Blue Nile's price for similar diamonds that came with a GIA Certificate





Exceptional diamonds!
Earrings truly exceeded my expectations. Incredible deal for stunning diamonds.





I love my earrings. The diamonds are of exceptional quality. They are near colorless and really sparkle.





She never wants to take them off.
They were perfect. The shipping / processing time was very fast and as always, the customer service for ordering, etc. was perfect. Thank you!





I was extremely pleased with the diamond earrings I purchased. They are beautiful and my wife loves them!





Great Stuff!
the Earrings look great. I liked the fact that I was able to pick my own diamonds and setting. They arrived in a couple of days without any hassle.





Beautiful set of earrings. She loved the Asscher-cut style. My purchase was for quality vs. quantity and the diamonds really sparkle!





Excellent attention to detail
These earrings were just as I expected. They are gorgeous! I find the screw post and little hard to use but it's worth the effort. The whole shopping experience was easy. I liked the shipping and packaging too. The earrings came with all the gemological reports in a nice vinyl folder for insurance.





Beautiful earrings!! She absolutely loved them! Shopped around at several jewelry stores and many other sites - you cannot be the quality, value, or price!! I will definitely be a repeat customer.





Earrings are beautiful!!
The customer service was excellent, the package arrived when stated, and the earrings are BEAUTIFUL.





Great service
Build your own diamond earrings was just what I was looking for. It offered the option to pick out the exact pair of diamonds I wanted along with a choice of settings. They were delivered on-time and were less expensive and of better quality than what I could find at local jewelery stores. Blue Nile delivered exactly what it promised. Thanks.
Sort by:
