Please choose your preferred language: English, Español, Français, 日本語, 简体中文, 繁體中文
Blue Nile Reviews
Classic Comfort Fit Solitaire Engagement Ring in Platinum (2.5mm)
Classic Comfort Fit Solitaire Engagement Ring in Platinum (2.5mm)
Enduring and elegant, this solitaire engagement ring is crafted in platinum with a rounded inside edge for comfort. Pair with the matching wedding band for the perfect set.
4.8 out of 5 (430 Reviews)
Shop Now
More Reviews
Results:  430 Reviews
Sort by:
4.8 out of 5 (430 Reviews)
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
Well, with the looks and craftsmanship or this ring :) looks like I will be married off for sure!
Richard - 
Perfect Engagement Ring
I shopped around at local jewelry stores, but I found I could get a larger, better quality stone through Blue Nile for the same price. I was a bit scared of making a purchase like this over the 'net, but the ring Blue Nile delivered was beautiful and exceeded my expectations. My fiancee loves it and I really couldn't be happier.
Anonymous - 
She loved the ring, and so did all her friends!
The online tool to create your own ring was amazing. When I saw the ring in the mail it was even nicer thatn I imagined. I would buy a ring from blue diamond again! When she saw the ring, her faced glowed like crazy. The quality of the product that we received was just exceptional.
Alessandro - 
I have bought 3 things from blue nile and every time I have ended up with a gorgeous piece of jewelry that my wife truly loves. I strongly recommend blue nile to anyone.
George - 
She loved the ring!
Everything about the engagement ring and wedding bands was perfect. They all arrived on time and were all as described. My fiancee loved it all and we couldn't be any happier with Blue Nile's service.
Patricia M - 
love the ring very much
beautiful ring and best value, I am very happy with this purchase.
Yongshen - 
Happy lady
I spoke to some friends about buying an engagement ring-half had used Bluenile and others had used jewelry stores. Using Bluenile was much easier and no one had to set me up with a wholesale jeweler to get a good deal. I got a much better ring within my budget and she enjoys the compliments she gets on her ring!
Anonymous - 
She loved the ring and was blown away
The ring was excellent quality. Customer service over the phone was top notch. Helped to get the right ring, with the right size band, with the perfect diamond---for the right gal
Anonymous - 
Glitter in GB
The website, phone contact at Blue Nile and the ring where all top notch. We had shopped in retail stores in the area and this ring was comparable in quality rating @ 30 % less than tne lowest local quoted price. Product was shipped on time and received when promised. I can not say enough good things about Blue Nile. Our son is thinking of popping THE ?. and after he seen his mothers ring he will be shopping Blue Nile.
Beautiful ring. She loved it at first sight which is probably why she agreed to marry me. Haha
Anonymous - 
Perfect Engagement
My beautiful girlfriend was pleasantly surprised when I presented this ring to her on a quiet beach. The ring made this romantic setting complete. Each day we appreciate the quality of the ring: the diamond sparkles with a rainbow of colors, and the platinum band looks stunning on her small hand.
Aaron - 
She cannot get over how beautiful the ring is!
My fiancee loves the ring so much that she that you will catch her smiling and looking at it when she thinks no one is looking. Blue Nile offers superior products for less than department stores. We will be ordering our wedding bands from Blue Nile for sure!
Robert - 
My fiancee loves the ring, so does everyone else who sees it.
Blue Nile custom diamond rings was the perfect choice. I could select the perfect diamond, for the perfect price, for the perfect girl. I couldn't be happier with the ring I chose and the customer service I received. World class.
Jordan - 
She thought it was perfect
The website was very useful and customer service was great. I could request changes with a simple call. The ring was beautiful and my fiance loved it.
Anonymous - 
Stunning diamond with exceptional craftmanship!
She said yes and her face was shining when she saw the diamond. It is definitely beautiful and Blue Nile made the process very easy and educational for me. I would definitely come back and buy again.
Alan - 
she loves her ring
beautiful job!! i was sceptical about spending that kind of money on something i hahnt seen but was very pleased. tried and tried to spend my money local but couldnt even come close to the price!! excellent value
brian - 
Everyone impressed by ring quality
Beauty of ring surpassed my expectations.
The exellent experience with blue nile
At first I think it was a very hard mission for me to choose an engagement ring for my girlfriend. But after some friends recommand Blue Nile to me, it makes everything easilier. I can choose the one we loved most. When my girlfriend found the ring was a little large, we can change the ring from one size to another without extra fees. Thanks, Blue Nile.
Miao - 
The ring was absolutly perfect!
After visiting several jewelry stores in my local area, and after a brief visit to NYC's Diamond District while traveling on business, I found my on line experience to be the best fit for me. I was easily able to compare many diamonds and found what best fit the 4C's for me. I choose a platinum setting that was perfect. Thank you Blue Nile!
Peter - 
Unbelievable quality! The diamond was beautiful!
Anonymous - 
The engagement ring was beautiful!
This was our second purchase from Blue Nile and we've been consistently impressed. The engagement ring was exactly what we were looking for and just what we ordered. Keep up the good work.
Tristan - 
She liked the ring.
The stone was as I had expected. The ring setting was well made.
Anonymous - 
The online process was extremely user-friendly and covered all the the details. The customer service people were quick to respond when I judged the ring size incorrectly. I recieved the replacement less than 10 days after sending.
Greg - 
What A Pleasure
It took time to find the perfect diamond for her ring, but the filtering feature of the site made it super easy to quickly see the available stock. I knew right away when I had found the rock, and the pictures confirmed my choice. I knew she'd love it. Buying and receiving the ring were an absolute breeze, and the free resizing is great too! Thanks Blue Nile!!
Anonymous - 
The quality is exactly as stated. Blue Nile is a site that can be trusted. The price was also exceptional.
sheila - 
The right ring
The Blue Nile diamond ring with the ideal cut has the wow factor - a few people have remarked they haven't seen a diamond which sparkled with so many colors. Also, I had read that the comfort fit ring might need to be ordered in a larger size than the actual ring size to fit, however the 2.5mm comfort fit ring in a custom three-quarter size fit her finger (of same size) perfectly and she finds it to be very comfortable.
Ted - 
My fiancee loved her engagement ring!
My fiancee was so happy with her ring that since our engagement, she only wears her ring periodically out of fear of losing or damaging it. I have no doubt that if I had spent the same amount of money on another ring at another store, the quality of it would not compare to that of the ring we purchased from Blue Nile. We will undoubtedly be purchasing our wedding bands from BN!
Justin - 
she loved it!
For those who've done the research, the Blue Nile website is excellent for searching for the perfect stone by a multitude of parameters (including things like polish, symmetry, price/carat, etc.) This would be difficult to do at a bricks & mortar jeweler. Online GIA reports very helpful. Only drawback is being unable to actually SEE what YOUR stone would look like in YOUR setting. Having said that, we were not disappointed. Highly recommended.
Anonymous - 
Great engagement ring
Great service, great product, and best prices around.
Norman - 
Great Deal on Engagement Ring
The purchasing process was straightforward and simple. I paid much less for the ring than what the appraisal documents read. I am very pleased with the ring and so is my fiance!
Jeffrey - 
Ratings-Only Reviews for Classic Comfort Fit Solitaire Engagement Ring in Platinum (2.5mm) :
4.5 out of 5 (2 Reviews)

Sort by:
Connect for Special Offers and News: